329. 12 Days of Recipes, Day 8: Best Cookie Exchange Recipes

Home Newsroom 329. 12 Days of Recipes, Day 8: Best Cookie Exchange Recipes

With cold, wet weather and the season’s first measurable snowfall expected today, here’s a fun indoor activity you can do alone or with your kids.  Forget about the fire, why not just heat up by the oven as you try your hand at some of my favorite holiday cookie recipes?  These are great for a cookie exchange, as gifts for neighbors or just for enjoying at home with your family.  And they’re the highlight today for Day 8 of our 12 Days of Recipes series here at 365Barrington.com.

12 Days of Recipes - Day 8

For us, we have a little different criteria for the best cookie exchange recipes.  The cookies have to look festive.  They have to be easy enough to crank out six dozen in about 2 hours. The recipe has to be basic enough to triple with ease.  And, of course, we want to skip all fussy ingredients.

Post - Best Holiday Cookie Recipes

Candy-Dipped Chocolate Cutout Cookies

We think any basic cookie, such as oatmeal, sugar or chocolate cutout cookie dipped in melted white chocolate and then crushed candy cane pieces is a holiday best.  White chocolate and candy cane pieces are a perfect mouthful of holiday flavor, and with any good cookie base, they are a true crowd pleaser. Below is a recipe that does this with chocolate cutout cookies.  You can do something similar with crushed pistachios, m&m pieces or sprinkles in place of the candy canes…


2 sticks butter, softened

1 cup powdered sugar

1 egg

2 teaspoons vanilla

2-1/2 cups flour

1/2 cup cocoa powder

1/2 teaspoon salt

1 cup white chocolate chips

½ cup crushed candy canes

Cream the butter with the powdered sugar. Add the egg and vanilla and mix to combine.  Add the flour, cocoa powder and salt, and mix together to create dough.  Wrap dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate at least one hour.  Preheat the oven to 375 degrees F.  Roll out the cookie dough and cut out the cookies with a Christmas tree shaped cookie cutter, or basic shapes such as squares or circles Bake for 8 minutes.  Cool cookies completely.

Melt white chocolate chips in microwave-safe bowl for 50 seconds.  Stir until chocolate is smooth. Microwave additional 15-second intervals if needed.

Peppermint No-Bake Cake Balls

Yes, cake balls are all the rage. They are both adorable and delicious. But the ordinary ones would never make it onto this “best” list as no one but the Cake Boss could make 6 dozen in less than 2 hours – or without a grand mess in the kitchen. However, the no-bake version, while slightly less elegant tasting (they are heavier and sweeter than a traditional cake ball) fit the quick and easy bill.  And they look just as adorable!

Post 300 - Peppermint Cake BallsIngredients:

1 package white or chocolate cake mix

2 canisters white or chocolate frosting

1 cup flour

White chocolate or almond bark

8 candy canes, smashed

Combine cake mix, frosting, flour and half candy cane pieces.  Roll into balls, place on wax paper, and place in freezer for at least one half hour.  Melt chocolate or almond bark. Roll balls in melted chocolate.

Place on waxed paper, and then sprinkle with remaining candy can pieces.

Chocolate Pretzel Bites

Chocolate Pretzel Bites are a must have for my family during the holidays.  Lucky for me they are super easy to make, and I can make mini batches in between other kitchen tasks.  The hardest part is finding circle-shaped pretzels.  I have the best luck finding them at Jewel, but you can also use large pretzel rods, or the square waffle shaped pretzels as a substitute.


2 bags pretzels

2 bags white chocolate chips

1 large bag M&M’s

Spread pretzels on wax paper. Melt white chocolate chips in microwave-safe bowl for 50 seconds.  Stir and microwave an additional 50 seconds. Stir again until chocolate is smooth.  Microwave additional 15-second intervals if needed.

Drip chocolate from a spoon into center of pretzels.  Press an M&M into the center.

Holiday Sprinkle Sandwich Cookies

Sandwich cookies rank high on everyone’s favorite list because of the rich sweetness in the filling.  Cake batter cookies are extremely easy to make and reliable as well, making these an easy additional to our “best holiday cookies” list.


2 packages Devil’s Food cake mix

4 eggs

2/3 cup oil

1 canister vanilla frosting

green and red sprinkles

Combine cake mix eggs and oil to make cookie dough. Roll dough into quarter-sized balls.  Press onto cookie sheets and bake at 375 for 8-10 minutes.  Cool cookies. Place a spoonful of frosting in between two
cookies, press together slightly, and roll sides in sprinkles.

Pistachio Pomegranate Pudding Cookies

These delightful and delicious cookies are perfect for your holiday cookie exchange, using festive red dehydrated pomegranate seeds (or cranberries) and green pistachio pudding in a basic sugar cookie recipe. They are simple but elegant and rich-tasting. And they can be made ahead and frozen.

Post 300 - Pistachio Pudding CookiesIngredients:
Makes 2 dozen cookies

1 cup butter, softened

1 cup sugar

2 eggs

1 (3.5 ounce) package instant Pistachio pudding

2 cups flour

1/2 teaspoon salt

1 teaspoon vanilla

1/2 cup dried pomegranate seeds (or dried cranberries)

Heat oven to 350 degrees. Cream butter and sugar.  Blend in eggs and pudding. Sift dry ingredients together and stir to combine all ingredients, including your choice of add-ins (optional).  Place by rounded spoonfuls on baking sheet. Bake for 10 minutes.



About the Author

Kelly Donlea is a Barrington mom, chef, cookbook author the owner of Organizing Dinner, a company that brings sensible cooking solutions to busy people. She has published several cookbooks and one of her specialties is helping parents plan family meals with fewer trips to the grocery store. Kelly also offers cooking classes and demonstrations in your home or public facility. To learn more about Kelly, her recipes and her services, you’ll find her Facebook page by clicking HERE and her website at OrganizingDinner.com. Kelly is going to be sharing recipes, cooking tips and special features about chefs and popular menu items at area restaurants right here at 365Barrington.com.

To explore more of Kelly’s recipes in your own kitchen, her cookbooks are your best companion and they also make great holiday gifts! CLICK HERE to read more about her books, titled 70 Meals One Trip to the Store and 30 Spectacular Salads.

Please join us as we discover local culinary treasures and new kitchen classics in our weekly food feature here at 365Barrington.com called “Barrington Eats” with Kelly Donlea!

If you’d like to us to feature you favorite chef, restaurant or food store or if you have a food related question that you’d like Kelly to answer, make a quick stop at the 365 Barrington Suggestion Box and leave us a note in the form which you’ll find by clicking HERE or simply leave your comment in the box below.

There are no comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Barrington Today

365Barrington Partners

From the Community

We the female. Done by talented Tanya. ☺️#palatinemoms #deerparkmoms #wowspa #barringtonillinois #barringtonscoop #365barrington ...

3 0

This weathers got us making Frappés pretending we’re in Greece (if you close your eyes) !! ☀️ if only you could smell this BBQ... 🤤

#foodbeast #fabfoodchicago #bbqporn #eatingfortheinsta #chicagofood #foodpic #thedailybite #chicagoeats #chicagocraves #chicagofoodauthority #chicityfoodie #chicagofoodbloggers #thelatestindulge #phaat #foodporn #brunch #goodeating #bbqsmoker #dinersdriveinsanddives #chicagofoodcoop #chicagoland #chicagobbq #chicagofoodgoals #thrillist #phoneeatsfirst #dishroulette #eeeeeats #infatuationchi #365barrington #barrington

15 1

Let It Be Us is searching for a home in the Kankakee or South Suburb areas. The brother is 5 years old and the girl is 12. They are sweet kids hoping to remain together.

Licensed homes that are interested can fill out their information on our home page ♥️

Thank you as well for sharing! #LetItBeUs

5 1

Today is International Women's Day and we'd like to kick today off by recognizing our fearless Founder & Executive Director, Susan McConnell!

Susan was featured last week on cbschicago for Women's History Month and the work she has done with Let It Be Us ♥️ Take a look at the piece at the 🔗 in bio and celebrate the women in your life all month long ♥️

#LetItBeUs #internationalwomensday #womenshistorymonth

1 1

Luby Group Listings

113 S Cook Street Barrington, IL 60010
Commercial For Sale
- Active

Retail storefront in prime pedestrian location in downtown Barrington surrounded by Village shopping, restaurants, and steps to the Metra train station. Great opportunity to own a high visibility space, currently vacant, ready for you to move in and

1406 Dunheath Drive Inverness, IL 60010
Single Family Home For Sale
- Active Under Contract

Family is sure to enjoy ice skating, hockey, kayaking & fishing in a stocked lake in their own back yard. Over 4,200 square feet of living space, this home has dramatic volume entry. It offers a spacious formal living room + separate dining room and

New Listing - a week online
51 Whitetail Lane Barrington, IL 60010
Single Family Home For Sale
- Active Under Contract

Excellent value and great location - Close to Barrington Village and Metra! Situated on a private cul-de-sac with beautiful 1.4 acres. Enter through a sunny, open 2-story foyer with hardwood floors. Large entertainers kitchen opens to a comfortable f

New Listing - 2 weeks online
1100 Prairie Avenue Barrington, IL 60010
Land For Sale
- Active

Great opportunity to build your dream home on a half acre in Barrington right down the street from Baker Lake and Ron Beese Park. Located just over a mile south of downtown Barrington, this rare waterfront location is a few blocks away from award-wi